Are biscuits better made with butter or Crisco?

When it comes to baking biscuits, the debate between using butter or Crisco is a hot topic among culinary enthusiasts. Are biscuits better made with butter or Crisco? This is a question that taps into the heart of traditional and modern baking practices. Biscuits, a staple in many cultures, vary in taste and texture based on the fats used in their creation. This guide delves into the pros and cons of each, examining the history, science, and personal experiences to determine which fat reigns supreme for the perfect biscuit.

Discover if butter or Crisco leads to the best biscuits. Get expert insights for perfect results every time. Bake the debate away!

The History of Biscuit Making

Embarking on a journey through the history of biscuit making, we uncover a rich tapestry of culinary evolution. This tradition, steeped in both necessity and ingenuity, mirrors the progression of societies across the globe. Now, as we slice through the layers of time, let’s explore the transformation from ancient sustenance to modern-day treat and see how this shapes our understanding in the debate between butter and Crisco.

Early Beginnings

In their infancy, biscuits served as a robust sustenance for ancient travelers and armies. Bakers would mix water and flour, then bake this blend to create a hard, durable bread. These early biscuits provided nourishment across unforgiving journeys, from Roman legionnaires to mariners navigating the high seas. They earned their name from the practice of baking them twice to draw out moisture and extend their shelf life.

The Evolution into Modern Baking

As we fast forward to the 19th century, the introduction of baking powder ushers in a new era for biscuits. This innovation allows biscuits to rise, giving way to the flaky texture that now tickles the palates of enthusiasts everywhere. The industrial revolution not only mechanized their production but also brought the joys of biscuit making into home kitchens. Initially, butter reigned supreme, lending its rich flavor and tender crumb to biscuits far and wide. However, the landscape shifted once more with the advent of Crisco in the early 1900s. This vegetable shortening emerged as a contender, boasting a different set of attributes, including longer shelf life and a distinct texture. Bakers now stand at a crossroads, choosing between the traditional allure of butter and the modern versatility of Crisco, each with its unique impact on the beloved biscuit.

Comparing Fats: An Overview

As we delve into the realm of biscuit baking, the choice of fat becomes a pivotal decision that influences flavor, texture, and nutritional value. This section aims to shed light on the distinct characteristics of butter and Crisco, two fats commonly used in biscuit recipes. By understanding the fundamental differences between these fats, bakers can make informed decisions and tweak their recipes to perfection.

What is Butter?

Butter, a traditional favorite in baking, is a dairy product created by churning cream until it reaches a semi-solid state. Renowned for its rich flavor profile, it enhances baked goods with a taste that’s both unmistakably comforting and indulgent. In the context of biscuits, butter not only contributes to a savory, melt-in-your-mouth experience but also affects the rise and texture due to its water content, which turns into steam during baking. Additionally, the type of butter — whether it’s salted, unsalted, or cultured — can subtly alter the taste of the final product. Active bakers often lean towards butter for that coveted ‘homemade’ essence it imparts.

Understanding Crisco

On the other hand, Crisco represents modern innovation in baking fats. Developed as a vegetable shortening in the early 20th century, Crisco is made from hydrogenated vegetable oil. It’s designed to be a neutral, shelf-stable alternative to animal fats. In biscuit recipes, Crisco has the advantage of creating high-rising, tender pastries due to its high melting point. This means it stays solid longer during the baking process, creating distinct layers. Moreover, Crisco’s lack of water content prevents gluten formation, making for an exceptionally tender texture. Bakers may opt for Crisco not just for its functionality but also for accommodating dietary restrictions, like lactose intolerance or vegan preferences.

The Science Behind Baking with Fats

Diving into the scientific underpinnings of baking, we discover that the type of fat used is not just a matter of taste—it’s a matter of chemistry. Fats are fundamental in achieving the right balance of tenderness, flakiness, and flavor in biscuits. They interact with other ingredients in complex ways that can transform a simple dough into a sublime culinary experience. In this exploration, we’ll unravel the intricacies of how fats behave in baking and the distinct outcomes they produce when using butter versus Crisco.

The Role of Fat in Biscuit Texture

Fat is a key player in biscuit texture, acting as a tenderizer that interferes with the formation of gluten strands. When you introduce fat into biscuit dough, it coats the flour particles, which in turn controls the amount of water absorbed and limits gluten development. This is crucial because less gluten means a more tender biscuit. The manner in which the fat is incorporated also matters greatly. For instance, thoroughly blending butter into the dough yields a cake-like texture, while leaving it in larger, pea-sized pieces results in flaky layers as the fat melts and leaves pockets within the dough. Here, Crisco often takes the lead for tenderness due to its higher melting point and ability to keep those layers distinct, while butter brings the added bonus of steam during melting, contributing to leavening and flakiness.

Flavor Profiles: Butter vs. Crisco

When it comes to the flavor of fats in baking, butter is the undisputed champion of richness and depth. Its creamy, slightly sweet taste with hints of caramelization upon baking gives biscuits a complex flavor profile that’s hard to replicate. Crisco, while neutral in taste, allows other ingredients to shine through, making it a subtle yet versatile choice for bakers who want to highlight additional flavors in their biscuits. The choice between butter and Crisco can greatly influence the end taste of a biscuit. Butter brings its own distinctive flavor, which can make biscuits taste more ‘buttery’ and rich, whereas Crisco tends to produce a more subdued, neutral-flavored biscuit, allowing the accompanying ingredients, such as buttermilk or sugar, to become more pronounced.

Health Considerations in Choosing Fats

When selecting fats for baking biscuits, it’s important to weigh not only their culinary properties but also their impact on health. Fats are a crucial dietary component, yet the type and amount we consume can affect our well-being. In this discussion, we examine the nutritional content of butter and Crisco and consider how dietary restrictions and allergies influence the choice between these fats. A well-informed baker can strike a balance between delectable treats and dietary sensibility.

Nutritional Content: Butter vs. Crisco

Butter, with its natural origins, is rich in fat-soluble vitamins such as A, E, and K2. Butter contains butyric acid and conjugated linoleic acid, substances that studies link to health benefits. However, it also has a high saturated fat content, traditionally thought to contribute to heart disease. Recent research, however, points to a more nuanced relationship between saturated fats and heart health. Conversely, Crisco is a hydrogenated vegetable oil, virtually free of cholesterol but has historically contained trans fats, known for their adverse effects on heart health. Modern formulations have reduced trans fats significantly, making Crisco more health-conscious than before. When comparing the two, bakers must consider both their dietary goals and the impact that each fat has on the nutritional profile of their biscuits.

Dietary Restrictions and Allergies

Taking into account dietary restrictions and allergies is an integral part of choosing the right fat for baking biscuits. Butter is a dairy product, making it unsuitable for those with lactose intolerance or a dairy allergy. It also contains animal fats, which might not align with vegetarian or vegan dietary principles. On the flip side, Crisco is plant-based and dairy-free, which often makes it the fat of choice for those with specific dairy-related health concerns or dietary choices. However, some vegetable shortenings may have soybean oil, which can be problematic for individuals with soy allergies. Each baker must tailor their choice of fat to accommodate the dietary needs and health considerations of their audience, ensuring that their biscuits are not only delicious but inclusive as well.

Are Biscuits Better Made with Butter or Crisco?

Baking Tips and Tricks

Mastering the art of biscuit baking involves more than following a recipe; it’s about honing a set of skills that transform raw ingredients into a mouthwatering finale. This guide aims to equip you with essential tips and tricks to elevate your baking prowess. From achieving the perfect rise to mastering temperature control, these insights will help ensure your biscuits are not just good, but great. Let’s delve into the nuanced techniques that can take your biscuits from flat to fabulously fluffy.

Achieving the Perfect Rise The rise of your biscuits can mean the difference between a good morning treat and a great one. It starts with the right leavening agent, typically baking powder or baking soda, which reacts to moisture and heat to create carbon dioxide bubbles. These bubbles are what give your biscuits lift. But it’s not just about adding the leavening agent; it’s also about how you mix it with your fats and the way you handle the dough. Overworking it can deflate those bubbles and lead to tough biscuits. To avoid this, mix until just combined and use a gentle hand to fold and shape your dough. Furthermore, ensure your leavening agent is fresh for maximum efficacy. The right rise is a game-changer and with these strategies, your biscuits will reach new heights — both literally and figuratively.
The Importance of Temperature Control Temperature control is a pivotal element in the science of baking biscuits. The temperature of your ingredients, the dough, and the oven can all significantly influence the end result. Using cold butter or Crisco, for example, helps maintain the dough’s structure and ensures that the fat melts slowly in the oven, contributing to flakiness. Additionally, preheating your oven is non-negotiable — an accurate baking temperature is crucial for even baking and optimal rise. Don’t forget to position your biscuits correctly within the oven; too close to the top or bottom can lead to uneven browning. By respecting the role of temperature in baking, you can produce biscuits with an enviable texture and color that beckon from the baking sheet.

Cultural Impact of Biscuit Making

The craft of biscuit making extends far beyond the confines of a kitchen; it’s interwoven with cultural identities and traditions, prompting the question: Are biscuits better made with butter or Crisco? This query not only concerns the technique but also touches upon the rich tapestry of heritage and preferences. Biscuits carry the flavor of history and the essence of the regions they hail from, serving as culinary icons that narrate stories of heritage, geography, and society. As we explore the cultural impact of biscuit making, we uncover the soulful connection people have with these beloved baked goods and how they have become emblematic of comfort and community in various cultures.

Biscuits in the Southern United States

In the tapestry of Southern cuisine, biscuits hold a place of honor, cherished as much for their buttery, flaky layers as for the sense of home they evoke. A symbol of hospitality, Southern biscuits are a testament to the resourcefulness and creativity of the region’s cooks, who historically worked with the ingredients readily at hand—flour, buttermilk, and lard or butter—to produce something extraordinary. The biscuit’s versatility and its ability to accompany a wide range of dishes, from savory gravies to sweet jams, have made it a staple on Southern tables. It’s more than just a side dish; it’s a cultural heritage proudly passed down through generations, each family with its own cherished recipe and technique.

Biscuits Around the World

The concept of the biscuit transcends borders, adapting to the tastes and ingredients of cultures worldwide. While in the United States, ‘biscuit’ refers to a soft, leavened bread, the term holds different meanings elsewhere. In the United Kingdom and many Commonwealth countries, a biscuit is what Americans would call a cookie—crisp and sweet. But beyond nomenclature, the essence of the biscuit as a comfort food remains universal. From the flaky layers of a French croissant to the spicy bite of an Indian khari biscuit, these variations reflect the local ingredients and palates. Each culture’s unique take on the biscuit enriches our global culinary landscape and shows us that the love for this humble baked good is a shared human experience.


In the exploration of whether biscuits are better made with butter or Crisco, we’ve traversed through history, science, health considerations, and cultural impacts, uncovering the nuances that make biscuit baking both an art and a science. The choice between butter and Crisco is not just about taste or texture—it’s about personal preferences, dietary needs, and even cultural backgrounds. Whether you prefer the rich flavor of butter or the consistent results of Crisco, the joy of baking biscuits is a universal language of love and comfort shared across kitchen tables worldwide. As you continue your baking journey, may your biscuits be flaky, your ovens warm, and your hearts full.

For a deeper dive into the rich history and cultural significance of biscuits, feel free to visit Wikipedia’s comprehensive page on the subject.

Bake on, and let every biscuit you craft tell its own delicious story.

Leave a Comment